Wednesday, May 21, 2014

Car intake scoop with 3D printing

In this post I go through the steps of designing a 3D printed prototype of a plastic product.

The project I am covering is a cold air intake scoop for a car that sees some track days. The scoop mounts under the front fender and connects to a flexible hose that runs up to the engine compartment. I have made one before for my car, but recently I was asked to sell one. This was also a good opportunity to document the steps of developing a 3D printed end product.




0. Skills shown and acquired:
- CAD modeling
- Designing a plastic product suitable for FDM
- Understanding rapid manufacturing; process and steps involved
- Taking advantage of slicer parameters in efficient prototyping

1. Dimensions and shape

First I observed the car for a convenient mounting location and wrote down some dimensions for existing mounting points. Then I sketched and cut a template of the intake side and trimmed it to desired shape while comparing its fit to the front fender. I also noted which way I wanted the hose to be pointed.

When the template was complete I scanned it and sketched over it in CAD. Next I sketched the shape of the other end to an appropriate place. From there it was easy to extrude the final shape between the ends and add the mounting flanges. I chose to leave the front facing end flat as it will provide good contact with the build plate. The flanges are designed to be easy for the printer to build with no significant overhang.

I left the model intentionally solid for reasons I will explain next.

2. Preparing the 3D print

The model is exported as .stl file and imported to the printed software. For this application I used Cura, which is free and open source. It combines two programs needed for the print; the slicer, which plans the physical moves, and the host, which sends these planned moves to the printer.

The slicer takes in parameters that affect the print. The most important is the layer height. For my printer this can range from 40 microns to 240 microns. Thinner layer height will naturally take longer to print, but the finish is smoother. For this project I set it for 150 microns. Next parameter is the infill rate. This can range from 0 to 100, 0 making the object hollow and 100 making it completely solid. As you can probably guess, I will set this to 0.

The print usually starts with several solid layers to build up the bottom and ends in the same matter, closing the infill inside. As I wan't air to flow through my scoop I will set the bottom and top solid layers to zero.

Now my object will be hollow, but very brittle. Luckily I can also adjust the amount of perimeters the printer will make around the edges of each layer as it builds the walls. With top and bottom gone and infill at zero, these perimeters are the only thing that will be printed.

This shows that starting with solid object has two advantages. Printing only the perimeters is very fast compared to zig-zagging infill moves, and I can adjust the thickness of the walls without changing the actual 3D model. This method is very effective and popular among those who print vase like objects.

The material used is ABS. It has high tendency to shrink when cooling and thus heated build platform is set to 115'C and the build chamber is heated to 70'C to prevent curling or cracking.

3. Print

This object is relatively big and took about two hours to complete. For slower machines the time could be near ten hours. Fast manufacturing also presents one of the obvious benefits of 3D printing; iteration. I started with three perimeter thick walls. This means the printer extrudes three loops in the shape of the object before moving up to the next layer. I started with thin walls just to test whether it was enough. In this case it was too flexible so I set the perimeter count to five. This produced a solid object with walls just the right size, but took near to five hours to finish.

Three perimeter walls were too flexible.

Five perimeters thick walls worked well.


Additional perimeters had to be removed after the print.

You may notice that the top was not actually open as you may have suspected. This is because it is not horizontal, and the strings closing the top are considered to be part of the wall by the slicer program. Removing these strings took less than a minute and was the only post-process needed.

4. The grill

I thought I should give a go at making a grill for the scoop as well. When designing it I chose to use the same trick used before and left the grill solid. This way I saved a lot of time not drawing the actual grill holes in the model and makes the density of the mesh adjustable.

Mesh and flange are adjusted with the slicer program.

Just like with the scoop I set the top and bottom infill to zero and outer perimeter thickness high. Only this time I set the infill to non-zero. This creates a nice mesh inside the perimeters normally intended to stiffen the object. The infill percent is completely parametric so again I can find a suitable value without actually doing anything to the simple 3D model. Spacing of about 5 mm was obtained with the infill set at 15%.

The flange in the grill would have been easy to model, but I chose to create it with the slicer program too. It is called skirt and is used to improve the prints adhesion to the bed. The width of the flange is also parametric when created with the skirt option.

5. Further developing

This was a one off project that I have no intention of continuing. However I am more than willing to help anyone with a similar project or print more scoops for people who are interested.

To mass produce this product one should make it a generic model that fit's more cars. Even if created for a car community in larger numbers (still less than 50) I would probably go with FDM methods.

Possible addition for brake cooling.

I also played with the idea of adding smaller scoops for brakes, but this turned out difficult as the original scoop was not designed this in mind.



3 comments:

  1. I always found worth content here,Would like to visit again.Keep posting interesting articles like this..
    Plastic Scoop Manufacturers

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks for sharing your valuable information.I found it very useful.Keep posting amazing content like this.Plastic Scoop Manufacturers

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yes definitely this type of blogs are really help for people great job. Visit: Product Development

    ReplyDelete